Closing arguments concluded in Sidney Moorer obstruction of just - WMBFNews.com, Myrtle Beach/Florence SC, Weather

Closing arguments concluded in Sidney Moorer obstruction of justice trial, jury to be charged

Tammy Moorer's relative Donald Demarino testifies in Sidney Moorer's trial. (Source: WMBF News) Tammy Moorer's relative Donald Demarino testifies in Sidney Moorer's trial. (Source: WMBF News)

CONWAY, SC (WMBF) – Both sides rested their respective cases and gave their closing arguments to the jury before turning the case over to them in the obstruction of justice trial for Sidney Moorer.

The defendant chose not to testify on his own behalf. He appeared emotional at times, dabbing at his eyes with a paper towel.

Judge Markley Dennis began charging the jury at 4 p.m. Wednesday. If convicted, Moorer faces up to 10 years in prison.

The third day of the obstruction of justice trial for Sidney Moorer included testimony by a forensic expert specializing in analyzing cell phone location data and from Tammy Moorer's cousin, who said Sidney Moorer showed him “something” on a cell phone indicating that Moorer knew more about Heather Elvis’ disappearance than what he told police.

Michael Melson, an expert witness for the prosecution provides software to investigators that analyzes cell phone records and gives visual representations of that data. Melson showed a presentation that detailed cell phone location information for Elvis’ and Sidney Moorers’ phones in December 2013, the month Elvis went missing.

The analyzed data showed that, among other things, the last calls placed by Elvis’ phone were in the early morning hours of December 18, and the cell phone towers used were consistent with the phone being located at Peachtree Landing at that time.

Melson also said there was a gap in data between 1 a.m. and 3 a.m. on December 18, which defense attorney Kirk Truslow had Melson contend could possibly have been due to a dead cell phone battery. Moorer’s location data appeared to confirm that he did place a phone call to Heather Elvis from a pay phone on 10th Avenue in Myrtle Beach. The state has argued that Moorer initially lied to police about this call, hindering their investigation and leading to the obstruction of justice charge.

Truslow grilled Melson on the possibility that the location data is inaccurate, as either phone may have used a different tower, if cell phone traffic on the closest tower to the phone was enough to jam it up. Melson said that 1 a.m., it was unlikely that the closest cell phone tower would have been jammed.

The next witness called was Donald Demarino, a cousin of Tammy Moorer, Sidney Moorer’s wife. He testified that after Elvis’ disappearance, Moorer showed him “something” on a cell phone indicating that Moorer had more information about Elvis' disappearance than what he told police. What was shown was not disclosed during this trial.

The defense asked Demarino if he was charged with obstruction of justice after not taking the information revealed to him to police. Demarino said he was not charged. 

The state rested its case after Demarino was called down from the stand, and the jury was sent on their lunch break until 2 p.m.

Watch the first part of the Facebook Live stream of the third day of the trial here:

Watch the second part of the Facebook Live stream of the third day of the trial here:

Related Stories:

Day 2:

Day 1:

Copyright 2017 WMBF News. All rights reserved.

Powered by Frankly