CHARLESTON, SC (WCSC) - When it comes to the strength of animal cruelty laws in states across the nation, South Carolina is at the back of the pack. The seizure of 45 dogs and the discovery of 200+ skeletons at a man's home in Goose Creek Monday got Live 5 News hunting down the facts, trying to figure out why the state's laws are don't stack up.
"They're very weak," says Joe Elmore, CEO of the Charleston Animal Society.
When it comes to cruelty laws, Elmore says South Carolina is in the bottom five nationally in strength. The Humane Society of the United States ranks the Palmetto State number 47 out of 51.
"It's extraordinarily frustrating," says Kim Kelly, South Carolina's Director of the Humane Society of the United States.
"It's very difficult to know that someone is abusing animals and not just one or ten animals but hundreds of animals and not be able to get a conviction," says Kelly.
The Humane Society Director has been working on a bill to give abusive owners in South Carolina longer jail time and require them to pay higher fees if convicted of hurting their animals.
But the bill, like many before it, is in limbo.
Kelly says the wait for change is painful. She says the more time passes more "animals suffer in South Carolina."
Under current state laws, Kelly says owners aren't required to give animals veterinary care.
There is no bonding law on the books in South Carolina. That means animal control and police are less likely to make major seizures and arrests because owners don't have to foot the bill for care while awaiting trial.
28 states have bonding laws for animal cruelty which saves the money of taxpayers, municipalities and non-profit clinics when large-scale rescues are made.
30 states have future ownership bans or restrictions for convicted offenders. South Carolina is not one of them.
If someone is convicted of animal cruelty charges in one of those 30 states, a judge can decided whether they are allowed to have animals again. If the decision is 'no' - then the defendant can face a time restriction or lifetime animal ban in that state.
Kelly says there is no law prohibits the private ownership of dangerous exotic animals 'including tigers, lions, chimpanzees, exotic snakes and even bears."
She also says South Carolina is one of ten states that doesn't have laws against felony cockfighting.
"We're surrounded by felony states which makes us even more appealing to cock fighters," she says.
On top of those lack of laws, Elmore says the wording in current S.C. cruelty laws is open ended. He admits even the state's largest pet-friendly organizations don't know whether or not it's legal to shoot an animal in South Carolina.
"There are a lot of exemptions and loopholes in there now," says Elmore. "There's a lot of ambiguity like what is ill treatment? What is cruelly killing an animal?"
Elmore and Kelly say the battle to beef up laws is just beginning and they won't stop trying to change the rules until cruelty laws have a much bigger bite.
"We have a lot of work to do in South Carolina," says Kelly. "A lot of work to do."
Current animal cruelty laws in South Carolina are as follows:
§ 47-1-40. Ill-treatment of animals generally.
(A) Whoever knowingly or intentionally overloads, overdrives, overworks, ill-treats any animal, deprives any animal of necessary sustenance or shelter, inflicts unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal, or by omission or commission knowingly or intentionally causes these things to be done, for every offense is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment not exceeding sixty days or by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars nor more than five hundred dollars, or both, for a first offense; by imprisonment not exceeding ninety days or by a fine not exceeding eight hundred dollars, or both, for a second offense; or by imprisonment not exceeding two years or by a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars, or both, for a third or subsequent offense. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a first offense under this subsection shall be tried in magistrate's or municipal court.
(B) Whoever tortures, torments, needlessly mutilates, cruelly kills, or inflicts excessive or repeated unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal or by omission or commission causes the acts to be done for any of the offenses is guilty of a felony and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment of not less than one hundred eighty days and not to exceed five years and by a fine of five thousand dollars.
(C) This section does not apply to fowl, accepted animal husbandry practices of farm operations and the training of animals, the practice of veterinary medicine, agricultural practices, forestry and silvacultural practices, wildlife management practices, or activity authorized by Title 50, including an activity authorized by the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources or an exercise designed for training dogs for hunting, if repeated contact with a dog or dogs and another animal does not occur during this training exercise.
Thursday, April 24 2014 9:50 PM EDT2014-04-25 01:50:44 GMT
SURFSIDE BEACH, SC (WMBF) – A WMBF News crews saw authorities remove a car from a Walmart parking lot after responding to a shoplifting incident. Authorities arrested the shoplifting suspect at the WalmartMore >>
A WMBF News crews saw authorities remove a car from a Walmart parking lot after responding to a shoplifting incident.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 9:47 PM EDT2014-04-25 01:47:03 GMT
FLORENCE, SOUTH CAROLINA (WMBF) Florence County said buying four new fire trucks is going to lower taxes. Improve response times and make up for a lack of manpower. The Olanta Fire Station is gettingMore >>
Council members of Florence County said buying four new fire trucks is going to lower taxes. Improve response times and make up for a lack of manpower.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 9:44 PM EDT2014-04-25 01:44:45 GMT
MURRELLS INLET, SC (WMBF) - A HAZMAT situation is underway at Wachesaw Plantation East on Riverwood Drive. Several emergency crews are on the scene working to assess the situation, according to Gary MocarskiMore >>
Five patients were transported to area hospitals after too much chlorine leaked into a pool at Wachesaw Plantation East on Riverwood Drive. More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 8:59 PM EDT2014-04-25 00:59:27 GMT
MYRTLE BEACH, SC (WMBF) - The head of Coast RTA has been running the area's only mass transit system for nearly 10 years now. And for nearly 10 years, he has had to endure the wrath from an army of criticsMore >>
After 10 years as CEO of Coast RTA, Myers Rollins points to a significant financial and operational turnaround under his tenure, while critics lambaste him for several missteps. WMBF investigated the controversy brewing at the Coast RTA to see who's getting thrown "Under the Bus"More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 8:44 PM EDT2014-04-25 00:44:32 GMT
DILLON COUNTY, SC (WMBF) – A convenience store clerk was murdered Monday night during an apparent robbery on Highway 9 East in Dillon County, officials confirmed. The clerk was closing the 20/20 ConvenientMore >>
A Dillon man has been arrested in connection to the convenience store robbery that happened Monday. More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 8:35 PM EDT2014-04-25 00:35:44 GMT
MONDAY AT 11PM – A local teenager disappeared last summer – but it was not without a trace. "When I found that car, I knew right then he was gone," said the grandfather of Zachary Malinowski, the AynorMore >>
Tune in to WMBF News on Monday at 11 p.m. as we uncover new details in the search for Zachary Malinowski.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 7:46 PM EDT2014-04-24 23:46:29 GMT
GALIVANTS FERRY, SC (WMBF) - A helicopter is en route to a burn victim on Highway 129. The victim was refueling a lawn mower and suffers injuries from a flash fire, according to Scott Thompson with HorryMore >>
A helicopter is en route to a burn victim on Highway 129. The victim was refueling a lawn mower and suffers injuries from a flash fire, according to Scott Thompson with HCFR.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 7:13 PM EDT2014-04-24 23:13:24 GMT
TABOR CITY, NC (WECT) - It could be months before the family of a South Columbus High School student knows what lead to the teen's unexpected death. Jaqwan Cephus McGill collapsed at a convenience storeMore >>
It could be months before the family of a South Columbus High School student knows what led to the teen's unexpected death.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 6:41 PM EDT2014-04-24 22:41:26 GMT
HORRY COUNTY, SC (WMBF)- Memorial Day weekend is fast approaching and with it comes the set deadline for completion of the current widening project happening on Highway 501. Crews are working to widenMore >>
Memorial Day weekend is fast approaching and with it comes the set deadline for completion of the current widening project happening on Highway 501. Crews are working to widen the road from two lanes to three on the inland bound lanes.More >>
Thursday, April 24 2014 6:32 PM EDT2014-04-24 22:32:05 GMT
Socastee (WMBF) - Standing by her side while she gave her acceptance speech at Wednesday night's Teacher of the Year Gala in Colombia was one of Jennifer Ainsworth's special needs students. "It was soMore >>
Standing by her side while she gave her acceptance speech at Wednesday night's Teacher of the Year Gala in Columbia was one of Jennifer Ainsworth's students with special needs.